So.
The Athena gaskets are deffinitely thinner and less quality, The Athena vale cover gasket requires RTV. Which is annoying, becasue then you never want to take off the valve cover, because of how messy the job is gonna be. The OEM gaskets have held up great. They ended up being the way to go.
Unfortunately I've had a piston seizure due to a failing oil pump, so now I am in the process of another rebuild... I'll have another report on gaskets when I can learn how nice the OEM head and base gaskets are to re-use.
As for other parts of the motor, alternator gasket, Clutch cover gasket... They work just fine, even putting them on dry. However the shape is not precise. They stick out from under the covers in some places, but not all... They are pretty poorly shaped.
Overall I will use them again where they are applicable and not vital. But go the extra $$$ and get OEM head, base, and valve cover gaskets.
Hope this helps.