Father Son 75 CB200T Rise From the Ruins

Turnturtle said:
Take a look at this article on the design of velocity stacks. Its one of the references to the Wikipedia entry on velocity stacks. He (Dr. Blair) discusses length, opening and shape. http://www.profblairandassociates.com/pdfs/Bellmouth.zip
elliptical it is! Thanks for the article!
 
Stacks are fine as long as there is a filter around the outside of them to keep children, small animals and stones out.

David Vizard repeated those Blair tests from an empirical perspective and the results were that the worst was a straight tube and the best was tapered and had a nice intake radius. In theory, there's a little more air to be had from an elliptical profile, but in the real world, not so much.

Vizard found that the effect on flow as anything from a 5.8% improvement to 6.7% deterioration IIRC. He tested 11 shapes and the best had a nice large intake bell radius and the worst had a sharp edge. Length seemed to be irrelevant in his tests.


Length is less of an issue because length relates only to tuned (resonant length) and that is RPM dependent. And by the time the 5th reflection arrives, it has so little pressure that it's largely an academic exercise. Out tests with multiple different stack lengths and different intake runner lengths have produced no meaningful results on the dyno or at the track.

Your results cannot be any less conclusive than ours, so whatever you come up with will be fine.

On CV carbs, all bets are off because they rely on pressure differential to lift the slides and that changes if the stock filter is removed. Turbulence doesn't seem to make much difference, but cross winds do...
 
teazer said:
1: Stacks are fine as long as there is a filter around the outside of them to keep children, small animals and stones out.

2:Length seemed to be irrelevant in his tests.

3: Turbulence doesn't seem to make much difference, but cross winds do...

Quotable Teazer...thanks Teazer We were trying to figure out our 12 foot intake to catch that first pulse:) we like big stacks in Texas and have major cross winds. (We live in tornado alley) Speaking of fast stacks... We have a little filly who ran 242 mph at the Texas Mile on two wheels :)

On another note did you know that Bret @ GFTP is building a Nixon replica? Sent him the same pix I showed you and he has been contacted by BIG D to build the glass for the 3 factor racer bikes.

"it's ok honey size doesn't matter" man have I heard that all my life :) that is why I believe in small things like our Lucky :) gotta go look for some elliptical 120mm+ should put us past the center frame like like this blue racer.
 

Attachments

  • image.jpg
    image.jpg
    263 KB · Views: 330
Phase one polish lower end first pic January 18 2013 and to date April 2 2013
 

Attachments

  • image.jpg
    image.jpg
    46.2 KB · Views: 838
  • image.jpg
    image.jpg
    1,018.9 KB · Views: 340
Valve seat check with denatured alcohol and then 30 minutes later
 

Attachments

  • image.jpg
    image.jpg
    47.9 KB · Views: 920
  • image.jpg
    image.jpg
    41.7 KB · Views: 913
When you find someone that does stacks for our bike let me know man.. you planning on running any type of filter with the stack?
.. and ya I started my teardown yesterday..gonna start the build thread after work today ;]
 
I used Steel Dragon Performance for my set. Price was reasonable and they did them in a custom diameter.
 
Sonreir said:
I used Steel Dragon Performance for my set. Price was reasonable and they did them in a custom diameter.

Thanks man, always appreciate advice from the Jedi Master ;]

,Dave
 
http://tinyurl.com/bn6hkmk

I have devoured Blair , Vizard , Kanemoto , Jennings , Cicale , NACA and Bernoulli over the years .
Aside from the confusion of thought this produced I have some real world experience to draw from .

For years it used to be 22 deg in and 17 out w/o question but only now has work started again to question the ideal venturi .

Teaze , I agree for the most part with all contained in your post save for intake runner length specifically and to a lessor extent velocity stack length . Our near exhaustive review of various intake tract lengths with the venturi placed at any and many positions along that tract resulted in findings much like your own . However this is where the results depart . Our investigations were initially applied to 750cc vertical twins and eventually a well known V-twin . The results differ in that carb venturi position along the intake tract did make a significant difference in booster/mixture signal under low vacuum , WOT conditions . You are correct , for a given diameter and length the cubic feet and feet per minute will not change significantly but available mixture signal will .

So for bull rings under 1/4 mile the venturi was backed off the head as much as five inches .
For 3/8 to 5/8 mile the intake runner was between 20 and 35% shorter .
For mile use the intake runner all but disappeared with the carb right up on the head .
Now for the not so obvious . the torque peak for these setups may have differed less than 2 Ft/Lbs at any RPM . Brake specific fuel consumption likewise was near identical . SO the obvious question becomes why change for conditions if all available research points to inconclusive results ?
The butt dyno . Pure and simple with a flat track bike controlled in a slide with throttle , accurate fuel metering is essential . To be able to predictably apply throttle resulting in a linear and immediate response at the rear wheel is essential . So with the results from real world testing we went back to the dyno with the addition of a throttle position sensor and looked at throttle response over time at different RPM . Sure enough venturi positions closer to the head reacted in a more linear fashion without delay at higher RPM and positions further from the head reacted better at lower RPM . Again the HP and Torque curves differed no more than a few percent for all instances .

Only from there as a baseline did we start changing rod length to stroke ratios and compression ratios to adapt to different track lengths and tract lengths . The investigation was worth more to me than most riders as I needed a bike that had that "soft spot" in order to control it . Better riders could make anything go fast but I needed every advantage I could build into the bike .

So back to the above link . I recently had a client/customer/pita that insisted on "pods" (argh! individual air cleaners ) on his bike . Once I had him talked into much larger filters I was able to hide velocity stacks inside the filters and all was right in the world . The other option was filters on the inlet of the stacks but that would have filled up the "triangle" and "wasn't proper cafe form " (again ARGH! ) .
I have used and recommended the aluminum tumblers to a variety of purpose built race induction systems over the years with good result . I personally have mounted them on everything from Holley four barrel with the choke milled off to single , twin , triple , and four , It's a simple and cost effective way to add stacks to anything if attention is paid to how they are attached .

I now return you to regularly scheduled updates .

~kop
 
Luugo86 said:
When you find someone that does stacks for our bike let me know man.. you planning on running any type of filter with the stack?
.. and ya I started my teardown yesterday..gonna start the build thread after work today ;]
yes gonna run a Uni. We want pix!
 
kopcicle said:
http://tinyurl.com/bn6hkmk

Once I had him talked into much larger filters I was able to hide velocity stacks inside the filters and all was right in the world . The other option was filters on the inlet of the stacks but that would have filled up the "triangle" and "wasn't proper cafe form " (again ARGH! ) .
I have used and recommended the aluminum tumblers to a variety of purpose built race induction systems over the years with good result . I personally have mounted them on everything from Holley four barrel with the choke milled off to single , twin , triple , and four , It's a simple and cost effective way to add stacks to anything if attention is paid to how they are attached .

I now return you to regularly updates .

~kop
Kop you are fricken awesome. Ok here is the goal in six years my son is gonna do Bonneville we talked to Keith at Big D and he said my son may be able to do the byob run at bonny...however that is at least 3 years away and many modifications. There is am alleged cb175 on YouTube claiming to have done the ton. I didn't see any hard evidence! As Hillary said it takes a village and secret service to party and go fast. So I am respectively requesting Teazer, Sonreir, and Your help. With that kind of experience I think we can get there...then the Texas Mile when he is older. Thank you!

We don't give a rats ass if it fills the triangle as long as we can go as fast as Lucky wants to go!
 
Sonreir said:
I used Steel Dragon Performance for my set. Price was reasonable and they did them in a custom diameter.
thanks Sonreir I will shoot them an email I also contacted Factory pro. My cam duration stock is 220 intake 225 exhaust megacycle is 256. So you basically did my calculations for me 142mm long :)
 
kopcicle said:
http://tinyurl.com/bn6hkmk

I have devoured Blair , Vizard , Kanemoto , Jennings , Cicale , NACA and Bernoulli over the years .
Aside from the confusion of thought this produced I have some real world experience to draw from .

For years it used to be 22 deg in and 17 out w/o question but only now has work started again to question the ideal venturi .

Teaze , I agree for the most part with all contained in your post save for intake runner length specifically and to a lessor extent velocity stack length . Our near exhaustive review of various intake tract lengths with the venturi placed at any and many positions along that tract resulted in findings much like your own . However this is where the results depart . Our investigations were initially applied to 750cc vertical twins and eventually a well known V-twin . The results differ in that carb venturi position along the intake tract did make a significant difference in booster/mixture signal under low vacuum , WOT conditions . You are correct , for a given diameter and length the cubic feet and feet per minute will not change significantly but available mixture signal will .

So for bull rings under 1/4 mile the venturi was backed off the head as much as five inches .
For 3/8 to 5/8 mile the intake runner was between 20 and 35% shorter .
For mile use the intake runner all but disappeared with the carb right up on the head .
Now for the not so obvious . the torque peak for these setups may have differed less than 2 Ft/Lbs at any RPM . Brake specific fuel consumption likewise was near identical . SO the obvious question becomes why change for conditions if all available research points to inconclusive results ?
The butt dyno . Pure and simple with a flat track bike controlled in a slide with throttle , accurate fuel metering is essential . To be able to predictably apply throttle resulting in a linear and immediate response at the rear wheel is essential . So with the results from real world testing we went back to the dyno with the addition of a throttle position sensor and looked at throttle response over time at different RPM . Sure enough venturi positions closer to the head reacted in a more linear fashion without delay at higher RPM and positions further from the head reacted better at lower RPM . Again the HP and Torque curves differed no more than a few percent for all instances .

Only from there as a baseline did we start changing rod length to stroke ratios and compression ratios to adapt to different track lengths and tract lengths . The investigation was worth more to me than most riders as I needed a bike that had that "soft spot" in order to control it . Better riders could make anything go fast but I needed every advantage I could build into the bike .

So back to the above link . I recently had a client/customer/pita that insisted on "pods" (argh! individual air cleaners ) on his bike . Once I had him talked into much larger filters I was able to hide velocity stacks inside the filters and all was right in the world . The other option was filters on the inlet of the stacks but that would have filled up the "triangle" and "wasn't proper cafe form " (again ARGH! ) .
I have used and recommended the aluminum tumblers to a variety of purpose built race induction systems over the years with good result . I personally have mounted them on everything from Holley four barrel with the choke milled off to single , twin , triple , and four , It's a simple and cost effective way to add stacks to anything if attention is paid to how they are attached .

I now return you to regularly scheduled updates .

~kop

KOP that makes perfect sense. What you are doing is to change the position of the jets so that they experience the greatest pressure differential a.k.a. signal. That will change fueling and sensitivity to jetting. A small change is almost immeasurable on a butt dyno in absolute terms, but it is capable of detecting changes in responsiveness and that''s where your jetting effects are paying off.

Lats time we dyno tested a CB175 based motor with three different velocity stacks, the best was a standard Honda plastic one from inside the airbox of a CB750 but the difference was basically within the range of experimental error/variance.

Our 175 race bikes all do more that 100 em pee aitch with fairings and small rider etc. Remember that a stock motor makes about 10-11 at the rear wheel and ours make over 20 on a good day and slightly less when they are tired.

Here's one we prepared earlier...

012_zps0daf4d96.jpg


As you can see the motor is more or less stock..............
P1010162_zpsa19f262d.jpg


That's a "Sloper 175" bottom end with CB200 head and custom pistons, race cam and lots of welding and machining. It's a smooth easy to ride bike but needs another 10hp to compete in that class. The exhaust is a mix of GSX400 Bandit tubes modified to fit with a custom collector and Midas special tail pipe. :-) Combustion chamber shape is very different to stock

For a speed run with a 200 motor there are all sorts of things to try as long as they stay within the rules. What are those rules in terms of engine classes and allowable modifications. I'm assuming that any modifications are allowed within a certain capacity class. Looks like you cn more or less do anything and choose a classification that fits what you built.
 
teazer said:
KOP that makes perfect sense. What you are doing is to change the position of the jets so that they experience the greatest pressure differential a.k.a. signal. That will change fueling and sensitivity to jetting. A small change is almost immeasurable on a butt dyno in absolute terms, but it is capable of detecting changes in responsiveness and that''s where your jetting effects are paying off.

Lats time we dyno tested a CB175 based motor with three different velocity stacks, the best was a standard Honda plastic one from inside the airbox of a CB750 but the difference was basically within the range of experimental error/variance.

Our 175 race bikes all do more that 100 em pee aitch with fairings and small rider etc. Remember that a stock motor makes about 10-11 at the rear wheel and ours make over 20 on a good day and slightly less when they are tired.

Here's one we prepared earlier...

012_zps0daf4d96.jpg


As you can see the motor is more or less stock..............
P1010162_zpsa19f262d.jpg


That's a "Sloper 175" bottom end with CB200 head and custom pistons, race cam and lots of welding and machining. It's a smooth easy to ride bike but needs another 10hp to compete in that class. The exhaust is a mix of GSX400 Bandit tubes modified to fit with a custom collector and Midas special tail pipe. :-) Combustion chamber shape is very different to stock

For a speed run with a 200 motor there are all sorts of things to try as long as they stay within the rules. What are those rules in terms of engine classes and allowable modifications. I'm assuming that any modifications are allowed within a certain capacity class. Looks like you cn more or less do anything and choose a classification that fits what you built.
"you can see it is basically stock!" Lol I am off to tare into a cb750 air box!!! Oh thanks for showing us your work! My son is gonna be as thrilled as I am!
 
Texasstar said:
"you can see it is basically stock!" Lol I am off to tare into a cb750 air box!!! Oh thanks for showing us your work! My son is gonna be as thrilled as I am!
the first air box I put my eyes on!!!! Enough to do 2 motors! Teazer may Godspeed and 10 more hp be with you and your 175!
 

Attachments

  • image.jpg
    image.jpg
    1.2 MB · Views: 360
Back
Top Bottom