Serious newbie with some questions on starting a build

bwhicks

New Member
I have been bitten by the whole Cafe Racer bug and the idea of building my own really appeals to me BUT...I don't want to bite off more than I can chew. I am a newbie and I do mean NEWBIE. I have some mechanical experience but not very much. Can I do simple auto repair? Sure. Can I tear down an engine and rebuild it? Uh...no.

So my question is two fold. First off, is doing a build something that someone who is brand new to motorcycles even do or is this "best left to the experts"?

Secondly, what bike is the best one to start with? I see tons of people working on the CB750's and such. Sounds like Honda is a favorite but there's only one problem, if I had my choice I would prefer British. It's because of the history and all that. My original thought was, if I want to build a cafe racer, let's build what they built back in the day (or at least as close as I can). That being said, I was wondering what makes more sense to work on, a Triumph Bonneville or Norton Commando or something else (BSA? Triton? other?). My criteria is three fold:
1. Ease of parts. I don't own a machine shop or have experience in welding so I would like to avoid custom parts. I'm looking for more of a build where I can buy parts and bolt them on.
2. Cost. I don't want this to turn into a money pit
3. Reliability. I am not an experienced rider so something that handles like crap or something isn't a good idea. I want cool but reliable cool. Ease of build cool.

So, can I get all of that in a British Cafe Racer or am I looking at a Honda? Can I even do this or is it more of a case where I would need more tools, more experience and more money than I have?

Ideally I would love someone to be able to say, "Sure, you can go with the 19XX British (insert name here) and the parts are readily available, not very expensive and with a little know how and patience you should be able to turn out a great little bike!"

I wonder though if it's more a case of, "There really isn't any way to do something like this without years of experience, quite a load of cash and the ability to create things that you simply can't find in the marketplace. Buy one that's already done because there isn't a hope in he!! of a newbie being able to pull off a British build."

So what's the consensus here?

Thanks for all the feedback on this hair-brained idea of mine. ;)
 
Reason people go with hondas

1. Tons of them around, and tons of parts available
2. Very cheap because of ^

so, buy a honda to build for anywhere from $300-$1500
or buy a brit bike to build for $2000 and up
 
I agree. Go with a jap bike. Don't get me wrong, I would like a brit bike for sure, but as far as money and easy/low maintenance, I'll stick with my trusty Honda.
 
Hi there!
I agree go 70's 80's Japanese high volume manufactured models.
Like Honda CB 400/4 550/4 750/4 or 350 twin
Yamaha XS 650
Suzuki GS range
Kawasaki Z550 Z650 Z750 Z1000
There will be stacks of aftermarket stuff for these and if you concentrate on getting one with a good condition standard engine that hasn't been fk'ed with and starts everyday all day long in all weathers you'll avoid a bucketfull of head aches.
As a brit living in britland ......... yup you can get your hands on most stuff for all the high volume stuff. And there are lots of bikes around, in the back of peoples garages ....... and that's where they will probably stay until they are dust. The British bike industry collapsed because it did not evolve fast enough. The Triumph Bonneville was about the only model that hung in there and stayed high volume in the 70's and 80's. And the states was the primary export market.
If you can get a late one with a good well looked after engine that would be your best bet by far. And you will be able to buy absolutely everything you could dream of for it. I think it would be worth researching which were the most reliable/ what bolt on mods, basically ignition and carburation are needed to get which ever model up to uber reliability. Then fill your boots!
 
Even with "bolt on" parts, youre not going to easily build a "cafe" bike. Not a very original one at least. Unless you spend a ton of money on hand made one off parts. As far as wht bike youshould buy, theres plenty of non Honda bikes out there that are cheap too. If you want to stick with honda, and seeing as this is your first bike, a smaller twin is what you need.
Anything from the late 60 - mid 70s. Look for a CB or CL 350, 200, 175...
Honestly though, you should go out and buy a bike thats in near perfect shape. Dont buy a project if youre not willing to do A LOT of work. Building a custom (even a mild one) motorcycle is not as simple as just bolting stuff on and riding off into the sunset. Unless as stated above you want some cookie cutter ride. And hell if you want that, just go buy a modern Triumph Thruxton and be done with it. You should also learn how to ride before you turn a single wrench. No point in spending money and time on something that your just going to lay down in a parking lot.
 
I don't really know year wise..............I would say most people are buying anything from '70 on up. Sure, there are earlier models, and some are building stuff past 1980. As far as parts go...............you can get anything you want! I would go look at different models (350's 450's, 500's, 750's etc) in person though,
the bikes are pretty small physically compared to modern day bikes. I guess it doesn't really matter, but as an example, a friend of mine was dead set on buying a pretty sweet cb350, but when he went to look at it, decided it was a little small for his 6'3" frame.
And don't forget, there are other Japanese bikes from the seventies people are building, I would guess Honda's are the most popular right now. I'd probably stay away from ebay , as far as complete bikes go...............................some people are asking waaaaaaaaaaaaaay too much money for bikes, and not just "cafe racers" but also bikes that are not even running. At all. If I ever need to buy anything I always check this site and sohc4 before anything. And this site is killer, so much information on here it's not even funny.
 
If you have limited mechanical skills, DO NOT BUY AN INLINE 4. (cb500/4, cb350f, cb400f, cb750, etc...) And for a first bike, I promise you most of the rides out there that are 500cc and over are a bad idea. Theyre heavy, theyre relativly fast, and they arent the best handling bikes in stock trim. Im not saying that you CANT rock one, but if I were you, Id look for a cb350 or cb200... At least to learn on, than upgrade to something bigger for your "cafe" bike. Also... Remember... 4 cyls = four of everything. 4 carbs especially...
 
VonYinzer said:
If you have limited mechanical skills, DO NOT BUY AN INLINE 4. (cb500/4, cb350f, cb400f, cb750, etc...) And for a first bike, I promise you most of the rides out there that are 500cc and over are a bad idea. Theyre heavy, theyre relativly fast, and they arent the best handling bikes in stock trim. Im not saying that you CANT rock one, but if I were you, Id look for a cb350 or cb200... At least to learn on, than upgrade to something bigger for your "cafe" bike. Also... Remember... 4 cyls = four of everything. 4 carbs especially...

TRUE TRUE TRUE! Figuring out a four cyl is WAY more difficult than a two. Four carbs is too big a puzzle for a newb. You will spend more time wrenching than riding... Two or even one, a thumper , will teach you alot without a hugh frustration factor... plus you can always sell a smaller bike for what you bought it for next season...

i'd trade my 4 cyl for a two if i could...
 
VonYinzer said:
If you have limited mechanical skills, DO NOT BUY AN INLINE 4. (cb500/4, cb350f, cb400f, cb750, etc...) And for a first bike, I promise you most of the rides out there that are 500cc and over are a bad idea. Theyre heavy, theyre relativly fast, and they arent the best handling bikes in stock trim. Im not saying that you CANT rock one, but if I were you, Id look for a cb350 or cb200... At least to learn on, than upgrade to something bigger for your "cafe" bike. Also... Remember... 4 cyls = four of everything. 4 carbs especially...

DSC00110.jpg

This can get daunting in a hurry. Don't get me wrong, I love my 1100, but tuning 4 carbs instead of 2 can be frustrating.
 
Yeah, good call on the 4cyl guys, didn't think about that. And I too would probably trade my 500four for a 450. ;D
 
Thanks for all the feedback. I have got my homework cut our for me, that's for sure. I'm gonna try to nail down exactly what I want and go from there. Right now, I'm all over the map. Bonneville, Commando, Manx, Honda, ect. I guess this is what happens when you are new at something. ;D

It's sounding like Honda might be the way to go.

One other question that popped in my head after reading some of the replies; it sounds like there is a strong sentiment that you want to avoid certain things when starting out (never thought about the 4 cylinder issue before). Is there a type of bike that I should not even consider because of difficulty or bad reputation? One of those "nightmare" bikes that no one wants to touch?
 
Yes go with a twin. Most parts availability will be found with Honda CB350, Yamaha XS650, or Kawasaki twin like KZ400 or 440. I have a CB450 nice bike but parts aren't as common as say a CB350. The less common the more expensive and frustrating the build will become. Don't worry so much about a killer custom from the start. Get a bike, do general maintence and tune up, then ride the thing before you go full on in the build. Make a budget from the start. Remember things like tires, chain, clip ons, seat pan, paint, ect. start to add up real quick. Hope this helps.
 
Find a bike you're interested in and research it before buying. Come here and ask for opinions. You'll get the info you're looking for.

I mentioned this the other day in a post, if you get a pre '76 Honda 360, check for two punch marks on the engine ID plate. Those two punch marks indicate that a recall was done. If you don't see those, I would probably pass unless it's a REALLY good deal. You have to take the engine apart to fix those recalls.

If you're looking to buy a running bike, it might be worth it to either get a compression tester, or have a friend or mechanic with one come with you. A motorcycle with low compression may run, but will require a top-end rebuild to run right. Just do a search before you go to look at the bike for "<insert bike model here> engine compression" and make sure it's up to snuff when you get there.

Once you get a bike, be sure to search out the factory service manual. You can probably find it online.
 
Here's my 4 pennarth - from someone who did it first time around [ and still at it! ].

Everyone's a virgin once. I was 13 when I started taking my James Cadet trail bike apart, and 15 when I built [ with help ] a 350cc MAC Velocette Sprinter [ Dragster].

If you are a competent general mechanic - you can build a bike. Specialised stuff you simply farm out. I ALWAYS had to farm out my machining and welding as I had neither the skill nor facilities. I swapped my knowledge of design and drawing as a means of bartering to keep costs down.

As to the donor. Forget British - unless you have deep pockets and are a closet masochist. I grew up with Brit bikes and soon swapped to Jap and Italian when I had the resources.

Any Jap single or twin will do the job - I agree about the inline fours as a first project - complex. Most Jap singles and twins [ 350cc plus ] are a damn sight faster than most Brit 500's [ and some 650's ] AND light years ahead in reliability.

But, hey - why go with the "let's all be different together" ?? The whole idea of building YOUR bike is to be different. Take a look at what's unloved [ therefore - cheap ] in your location. Here in the UK XS650s have gone through the roof in the past 10 years - but an XS500 is a quarter of the price. Ditto with GS 450 - I just bought a job lot of 450's [ 2 bikes ] for £150 [ $200 ?? ] and two and a half XS500's for £220 [$300??].

I have NINE projects on the go at the moment using the premis that " he who dies with the most toys, dies happy".

I'm missing a single from my stable - and as much as I'd like a Goldie, they're arms and legs to buy here - so, I'm looking at a Savage LS650. Sure, needs a bit of imagination - but they're CHEAP and have all the right bits - wire spoked wheels and an engine that looks a bit Goldie 'ish - and an exhaust that is pure Gold Star.

Don't be frightened off by the unusual - use that imagination.

Just go for it - and ask for / take advice from any of the many gurus on this site - can't go wrong my son.
 
heres an idea what a fully custom bike costs you, the builder.


ok, i bought my bike for 700 dollars. leaving out the cost of any parts that arent SEEN that dont need to be there ("performance internal engine parts"), but getting the parts that are commenly broken (for a cb350) leaves me out about 200 bucks on engine parts (cam chain, tensioner, etc).

all other cafe parts (clipons, rearsets, bump stop, custom tank etc) although im doing the work myself, still comes out to over a buck. if you keep tank stock and buy a cheap bump stop, maybe can be done for 500? good luck mounting it without it looking like crap without making proper brackets etc.


so yeah, id say it COULD be done for under 2000, not counting cost of tools/misc stuff... but its not gonna look very original, and will look slapped together.

if you want a mild "cafe", then do small things. clip ons and rearsets, to start. dont need a bumpstop yet. rebuild brakes, get the bike in as good condition as possible without breaking into the motor etc. suspension and brakes go a LONG way.


if i could do it again, i would ride the bike for MONTHS before getting into it. i would start small, then stop when your happy. now im waist deep in a bunch of parts that i see coming together as something beautiful, but its taken a LOT of money to have these pretty PARTS, and a lot of TIME. think about it. live and you learn.
 
I guess we're fortunate here in the UK - secondhand vintage parts - CR tanks, seats, clip-ons etc., are readilly available at a very reasonable cost.

However, I look at any project with a view that the bike is going to end up costing me - pretty well nothing! How so? I sell off all the unwanted parts to restorers !!!

Take the job lot of XS500's I just bought. Bought for £220 [ 2 complete and one 3/4 complete ] the lot.

Sell off - 3 stock tanks [ in good condition ] £130
2 spare wire wheels - £100
1 spare cylinder head and barrels - £80
4 side panels - £50
1 excellent stock seat - £75
1 headlamp assy - £25
2 sets of indicators - £40

etc.,etc.,etc.

I will do the painting myself and I expect to get the bike completed for well under £1000 - I also expect to get at least £500 for the spares I will sell off. I keep good records of the costs of my various projects [ yes I know - anal ] - so I'll let you know ..................................
 
i have my cost down to the dollar more or less... i just dont look at it so i dont smack myself out of how much ive spent already.
 
Another thing youll want to do is have a solid idea of what your finished bike will look and perform like. Well, at least what you WANT it to look and perform like. Do research. Find similarly finished bikes and search out the owners/builders. There is a ton of great info and inspiration here on DTT alone, but search every website you can. Than...
Do the real leg work. Go outside, and enjoy the real world. Check out any local bike shops you may have in the area. Attend every bike show you can and TALK to real people. Shake hands and actually make connections with folks. I love DTT, and it and the members here have been invaluable to me, but actually meeting up with like minded people is still the best way to learn. Just remember, no matter how much you learn, theres always someone smarter, and theres always something you havent heard/thought of. Thats the beauty of these old wrecks.
Showing a real interest goes a long way to making friends in the motorcycle world. Ask questions about the things you like, and more importantly HOW THEY WORK.
Theres a million pretty bikes out there that are nothing more than just that. Pretty. Pretty doesnt win races. Pretty wont keep ya from being stranded by your bike at 2am. Making sure you know how something works and its relation to the other parts on your scoot does though.
Another thing thats overlooked all to often is riding ability. What good is a fast and agile bike, if your skills are more suited to a moped? Take the local MSF course. Spend as much time as you can honing your skills as a rider before opening your toolbox. Again... A novice rider on a performance machine is not only dangerous to himself, but those around him.
These old bikes can be your best friend or worst enemy depending on how much youre willing to invest. Not just monitarily, but time and effort wise as well. If youre not willing to be a part of the vintage motorcycle world, than you should just buy a new bike, with a warranty. Not that theres anything wrong with that. The constant passion needed to keep 40 year old bikes running and safe isnt in everyone. No big deal. As long as youre out riding and keeping the love of motorcycling alive its all good. Just dont want to see another guy get frustrated and decide bikes arent for him because the difficulties in owning a vintage ride are too much.
So... Sorry for the long post, but I just want you to enter the wonderful world of old junk ( ;)) will both barrels loaded. Remember though, go out and actually meet people. Thats what this is all really about man.
 
Back
Top Bottom