OK - so, I try not to over-moderate or step in with what some might perceive as some authoritative stance on stuff. At the end of the day I try to remain a member, as anyone else is.
But I've also spent a lot of time over the last 6+ years trying to encourage civil, thoughtful, constructive discussion on the site.
General rule is a selling thread is not the place to debate the value of an item being sold. This has come up once or twice before and I've stepped in as needed to help direct the conversation. A seller and potential buyer are welcome to discuss openly should they choose the item being sold, it's relative value, the cost of various parts or what have you.
If people want to have a discussion about membership, contributions, how many posts a member should have before posting something up for sale etc, I'm happy to have the discussion on the site, in the right place, in general terms. These are ideas that impact everyone on the site and I'm happy to have a wide ranging discussion on the different topics where everyone will see it and participate.
The long-standing rule has been on selling threads that if you're not interested in the item, then that's that. Go find something else to look at.
Having some of your first posts be the selling of a bike without the benefit of any background story, pics etc. is never a good idea, but it has happened before and will happen again.
I appreciate the tone of the discussion has remained reasonable and nobody has deleted their account over it, but let's continue the discussion in the Lounge.