Hi Marla_do
It's a good question, but the truth is that there is no real rule to go by when decidig these things. The questions and parameters you want to work with are more a matter of perspective.. lines, personal taste, and last, but definitely not least.. aesthetics.
My personal taste in a build is to find balance. My preferred mode aesthetic is to go for a nice, simplified, symmetrical build with subtle mods that have to be really be lloked for. I'm not going for shock factor.. the bike must look good, it must ride good.. i.e. Geometry must be correct, and the bike must be able to be ridden hard and turn in well.
One thing you must be aware of... any time you either raise or lower the front or rear, you immediately change the handling characteristics. If you lower front too much, with too much rear height you will decrease the trail/rake so much that the front becomes very twitchy.. Alternatively.. if you add height to front, and decrease rear height, you increase trail/rake to the point that taking a corner is like steering a land barge.. or a Harley ;D *jokes.
So, due to my OCD and penchant for symmetry, I like to go for a near perfect level look. so that the tank and seat are in perfect level with the ground. I think it looks best.. well, it does to me. Plus learning forward with the rear jacked up too much can really fatigue your wrists on long day rides. Here are some photos from my current build as the ride height changed.
Standard XS750 with stock suspension as it was when purchased:
Here it is with standard rear height (300mm shocks) and the new RGV/R6 front end..
it sits 60mm lower in front now.. and although it's mostly level and nice and low looking.. it's still not quite right in height... still not the perfect symmetry..
then I put 330mm piggy back shocks in the rear and it's looking good:
As you can see in the image, it's on a wheel stand.. so it's sitting about 20mm off the ground.. but you can see how much better it looks with the 60mm drop in front height and a 30mm rear height increase...
But like I said, these decisions of what "looks good" are dictated by many factors..
- the look of each individual bike...
- the individual strengths and weaknesses of the aesthetics
- The desired overall finished look you're chasing
- and your personal OCD needs ;D
If you're building a cafe racer to be ridden daily or long weekend rides.. IMO, the level, symmetrical look not only has a nice balance to it, but it's ergonomic to ride.. It's great to have a day on the bike without having to pay the price with f*cked wrists at the of it LOL.. after years of riding rice-rockets with the bum up, the wrists hate me.. but I digress, the look of a classic cafe racer perfectly parallel with the ground just works nicely...