I looked at the Thorogood boots too. I agree, for the price they go for, they look pretty identical to the Redwings. (And they're made right here in my home state of Wisconsin!) The things I don't like is that they have a cotton lining- I don't care for any lining in my boots. I also don't like speed laces. Call me picky, or just downright fucking strange, but that's just how I am. I can also honestly say that these Red Wings are the most comfortable boots I've ever worn, right off the bat. I can't even imagine how awesome they're going to be down the road!