Untame
Been Around the Block
A huge thank you for this! Great advice all around. It is in my nature to always believe something can be better, but I do understand the danger of becoming "paralyzed by perfection." For me, I will likely get more satisfaction from the journey of creating this bike than from riding it when it is done. I almost expect to feel a let down (disappointment?) when it is finished. Then I will need to start another project (would love to build a replica 1927 bobtail model T racer with a Mercruiser 3.7 liter 4-cylinder with Ford 460 head, four Stromberg pots, and a powerglide tranny).I've heard of lost PLA casting but I've always wondered why people bother when there are filaments available that are made specifically for sand casting? Sure PLA is dirt cheap but if you're putting the time into designing the part to begin with, is $50 for filament really a big deal? For example:
https://machinablewax.com/wax-filament/
I've considered casting parts for a few vintage Ducatis but so far haven't taken the plunge. Mostly because I don't have the resources to do the actual casting, but the number of possible projects that could use it are growing. There is a makerspace type of place around here that could probably help but dag nab the membership is expensive. Those costs would go a long way towards buying the equipment needed to do it myself.
For now my 3D printed stuff has been limited to ASA and some PETG parts, but casting aluminum was one of the reasons I got a 3D printer to begin with. I really should get more serious about it. Especially since there's this tail light I've been working on that would be so much cooler cast than printed/painted...
In other news, as a retired development engineer (automotive exhaust mainly) I applaud your enthusiasm on the bikes you're working on, but as someone who's been riding for 30+ years I've been biting my tongue when I read your threads. Don't get too hung up on the theoretical part of what's "ideal". The details that make that intake runner ideal at 8650rpm will hurt it at 5800rpm or where ever. In your other thread, those angles you've calculated so precisely will change as soon as you sit on the bike or hit the brakes. I get the interest in it, and do not mean any of this as any type of flame, but keep the big picture in mind as you do all of this. Yeah you need a starting point so why not try to make it good, but the reality is a heck of a lot of engineering decisions in vehicle development are based on making it fit the space or using readily available parts, and the end result is perfectly fine for bikes that don't get judged by lap times in the hands of alien riders.
I know it's a cliche, but the idea of not letting perfect get in the way of good enough is SO true... don't fall into the trap that some engineering "ideal" is the best answer and you're somehow taking a short cut if you don't use it. A bike out there being ridden with less than ideal intake runners is a lot more impressive/fun than the one that has all the ideal numbers in it's CAD model but hasn't been built yet because you haven't quite worked out the ideal shape of the velocity stack or where to source 34.7mm diameter tubing or whatever.
Again, I don't mean any of this as a flame. These threads are much more refreshing than the typical "I got this Japanese cruiser free because it sat at the bottm of a lake for 20 years, where can I buy the kit to make it into a cafe racer OH LOOK A SQUIRREL!" threads.
As long as I'm going to take the time (and expense) to design/configure something I want to get as close to ideal as possible (within my mental and financial ability). That is why I have threads here, and that is why I am transparent with my thinking process. More than anything I need to learn what I don't know from you guys -- those with a lot of experience. I'm a huge believer in soliciting advice from as many sources as possible.
I've been deep into calculating the best jetting for the DCOE40, and I've realized that the new Spanish Weber DCOE 40 comes pretty close out of the box (maybe a little rich). The Keihin's have 28 venturis, and the Weber is 30 stock, but if I bore it to 69mm and use GS850 pistons it might be just right. At least I can just bolt it on and see how it works. Before going crazy buying jetting kits and chokes.